1
1. Waldo Pizza
WaldoSt. Louis-style & specialty pies$$
A Waldo family favorite with a huge menu of specialty pies and a choice of crusts. Food Network named its St. Louis-style slice, a cracker-thin crust under gooey Provel cheese, the best pizza slice in Missouri.
- Order
- A St. Louis-style thin crust, plus the garlic ranch for dipping
- Best for
- Family dinners and fans of thin crust
- Where
- 7433 Broadway St, Kansas City, MO
2
2. Northeast Pizza
Pendleton HeightsNew York-style$
A neighborhood slice shop doing proper New York-style pizza: big, foldable, blistered crust. There's a rotating pie of the day, so regulars check in to see what's on.
- Order
- The Brooklyn Margherita, or whatever the pie of the day is
- Best for
- A real New York slice
- Where
- Pendleton Heights, Kansas City, MO
3
3. Bacaro Primo
Brookside / Crestwood ShopsNeapolitan & Italian$$
From the team behind Earl's Premier, Bacaro Primo turns out blistered Neapolitan-style pies alongside a full Italian menu and a good wine list. It works as well for a date as for pizza night.
- Order
- The Rosa: vodka sauce, spicy 'nduja, fresh mozzarella and honey
- Best for
- A pizza dinner with a glass of wine
- Where
- Crestwood Shops, 55th St, Kansas City, MO
4
4. 1889 Pizza Napoletana
47th & Mission, Kansas City, KSNeapolitan$$
Handmade Neapolitan pies fired fast and hot, a block from Joe's original gas station. It also runs pizza-making classes if you want to learn the craft.
- Order
- The Honey Bee or The Prized Pig
- Best for
- Neapolitan purists
- Where
- 2876 W 47th Ave, Kansas City, KS
5
5. Pizza Tascio
North Kansas CityNew York-style$
A New York-style shop that sells big pies and slices with a few inventive house specials. The white pie is the one people come back for.
- Order
- The White Tascio (ricotta, sausage and broccoli) or a pepperoni slice
- Best for
- A quick slice north of the river
- Where
- 1111 Burlington St, North Kansas City, MO
6
6. Providence Pizza Co.
Westport & GrandviewNew York, Sicilian & Detroit$
Three crusts under one roof: New York thin, thick Sicilian squares and crispy-edged Detroit pans. It's a good stop when your group can't agree on a style.
- Order
- The East Coast pie with sausage, bacon, ricotta and hot honey
- Best for
- Groups who all want different pizza
- Where
- Westport, Kansas City, MO
7
7. Third Coast Pizza
Lenexa, KSChicago deep dish$$
Real Chicago-style deep dish in Johnson County, with tall crusts, sauce on top and cheese underneath. Give it time to bake and come hungry.
- Order
- The Second City
- Best for
- Deep-dish cravings
- Where
- 7820 Quivira Rd, Lenexa, KS
8
8. Johnny Jo's Pizzeria
Westport / 47th StStone-oven pizza$
A casual stone-oven pizzeria with red and garlic-butter pies plus classic sides. The garlic knots alone are worth the trip.
- Order
- A red pie with garlic knots and a cannoli
- Best for
- Easy weeknight pizza near the Plaza
- Where
- 1209 W 47th St, Kansas City, MO
9
9. Old Shawnee Pizza
Shawnee & Lenexa, KSSpecialty pies$
A local Johnson County chain with offbeat specialty pizzas. Its crab rangoon pizza, with crab filling, sweet chili sauce and crispy wontons, has a cult following.
- Order
- The Famous Crab Rangoon pizza
- Best for
- Something you won't find anywhere else
- Where
- Shawnee and Lenexa, KS (several locations)
10
10. Fortunati Pizza
West BottomsPizza$
A West Bottoms pizza stop that's an easy fit before or after browsing the neighborhood's antique and vintage weekends.
- Order
- The Pep Boi
- Best for
- First Friday weekends in the West Bottoms
- Where
- West Bottoms, Kansas City, MO
11
11. Clay & Fire
WestsideWood-fired pizza & small plates$$
A Westside restaurant with a wood-fired oven and a laid-back dining room. The square grandma-style pie is the local favorite.
- Order
- The C&F Grandma Pizza
- Best for
- A casual dinner date on the Westside
- Where
- Westside, Kansas City, MO
12
12. Minsky's Pizza
Many locations across the metroKansas City pizza chain$$
Minsky's has been a Kansas City pizza habit for decades, with locations from the River Market to the suburbs and crusts from thin to deep-dish. Reliable, everywhere, and good for game nights.
- Order
- The Prime Cut
- Best for
- Watching the game with pizza
- Where
- Several locations, including 427 Main St in the River Market